EntryLib: the issues that lower the Support scores of entrylib:2026.000009@v1, by the EntryLib rubric 0.7. For the authors and their agent: each issue lowers the scores of the claims it names, by the points given. Address what you can in a correction (a new version of the claimset) and submit it; the scores are computed again when it is published. Before submitting it, `claimset score` (or the MCP tool score) shows the scores it would have. Scores are computed by rules from the claimset file (EntryLib rubric 0.7): they check the record, not the science, and may change as the rubric and reviews develop. Rubric: https://github.com/entrylib/rubric/blob/main/RUBRIC.md Page: https://entrylib.org/p/2026.000009@v1#score ยท Scores as JSON: https://entrylib.org/p/2026.000009@v1.score.json PAPER: Support 74 (medium), the mean of its 7 principal claims; the lowest is C2 at 73. ISSUES, those of the principal claims first, most costly first: P1. Rests on evidence named without the observations the claim reports. Check: support_kind (group: support); costs up to 10 points. Lowers: C1 (-10), C2 (-10, from C1), C3 (-10, from C1), C4 (-10, from C1), C5 (-10, from C1), C6 (-10, from C1), C7 (-10, from C1), C8 (-10, from C1), C9 (-10, from C1), C10 (-10, from C1), C11 (-10, from C1). To fix: Support the claim with evidence the claimset records, citing the result entries or table rows it reports, or have its proof checked; for cited work, read the work in full and quote the passage the claim rests on from a captured copy (claimset extension review). P2. Limitation L6 (could bias magnitude, not mitigated): The study was designed and run by an agent under the supervision of the guarantor, who also wrote the review whose claims it tests (entrylib:2026.000008); no search was made for other simulation studies of these measures. Check: limitation (group: open); costs up to 6 points. Lowers: C1 (-6), C2 (-6), C3 (-6), C4 (-6), C5 (-6), C6 (-6), C7 (-6), C8 (-6), C9 (-6), C10 (-6), C11 (-6). Concerns: L6. To fix: Mitigate it with evidence, or narrow the claim's scope so that it no longer applies. P3. The paper cites no work. Check: no_references (group: context); costs up to 5 points. Lowers: C2 (-5), C3 (-5), C4 (-5), C5 (-5), C6 (-5), C7 (-5), C8 (-5). To fix: Cite in references the works the claim builds on, tests or departs from, and point to each from the relation, support or definition that uses it; when it tests a claimset, start from the works that claimset cites. P4. A principal claim reported without a plan recorded beforehand; the lab record shows every run. Check: exploratory_principal (group: plan); costs up to 3 points. Lowers: C2 (-3), C3 (-3), C4 (-3), C5 (-3), C6 (-3), C7 (-3), C8 (-3). To fix: Plan the measurement in the lab record or a registration before running it, or publish the lab record that shows every run. P5. Limitation L1 (reduces transferability, not mitigated): The test sets are independent draws from a fixed distribution. Real forecast errors are often correlated (forecasts of several horizons from one origin) and their distribution can change over a test period, so a real test set carries less information than the same number of outcomes here, and the choices spread more. Check: limitation (group: open); costs up to 1 points. Lowers: C2 (-1), C3 (-1), C4 (-1), C5 (-1), C6 (-1), C7 (-1), C8 (-1), C9 (-1), C10 (-1), C11 (-1). Concerns: L1. To fix: Mitigate it with evidence, or narrow the claim's scope so that it no longer applies. P6. Limitation L2 (reduces transferability, not mitigated): The candidates are fixed functionals of known distributions; no forecast is estimated from data. The results say which forecast each measure rewards and how reliably a test set shows it, not how forecasts estimated from data behave. Check: limitation (group: open); costs up to 1 points. Lowers: C2 (-1), C3 (-1), C4 (-1), C5 (-1), C6 (-1), C7 (-1), C8 (-1), C9 (-1), C10 (-1), C11 (-1). Concerns: L2. To fix: Mitigate it with evidence, or narrow the claim's scope so that it no longer applies. P7. Limitation L3 (reduces precision, not mitigated): Log-Laplace outcomes with b = 0.5 have infinite variance, so the expected RMSE of every candidate is infinite. The mean is still the preferred candidate of RMSE there, since the difference in expected squared error between two candidates is finite and favours the one nearer the mean; the expected RMSE values the run computed for this distribution are artefacts of the finite reference sample. Check: limitation (group: open); costs up to 1 points. Lowers: C2 (-1). Concerns: L3. To fix: Mitigate it with evidence, or narrow the claim's scope so that it no longer applies. P8. Limitation L4 (reduces precision, not mitigated): Normal and Laplace outcomes have a small positive density at zero, so their expected MAPE is, strictly, infinite. At the levels used (7 to 100 standard deviations above zero) no outcome at or below zero was drawn (T1), and the effect on the computed values is negligible. Check: limitation (group: open); costs up to 1 points. Lowers: C4 (-1). Concerns: L4. To fix: Mitigate it with evidence, or narrow the claim's scope so that it no longer applies. P9. Limitation L5 (reduces precision, not mitigated): The candidates are the quantiles at levels 0.01 apart, the mean and the minimisers, so a choice is resolved to the nearest candidate; spreads of choices narrower than about 0.01 quantile levels are not resolved. Check: limitation (group: open); costs up to 1 points. Lowers: C8 (-1), C9 (-1), C10 (-1), C11 (-1). Concerns: L5. To fix: Mitigate it with evidence, or narrow the claim's scope so that it no longer applies. CLAIMS: score (band): issues C1: 84 (high): P1 (-10), P2 (-6) C2: 73 (medium): P1 (-10), P2 (-6), P3 (-5), P4 (-3), P5 (-1), P6 (-1), P7 (-1) C3: 74 (medium): P1 (-10), P2 (-6), P3 (-5), P4 (-3), P5 (-1), P6 (-1) C4: 73 (medium): P1 (-10), P2 (-6), P3 (-5), P4 (-3), P5 (-1), P6 (-1), P8 (-1) C5: 74 (medium): P1 (-10), P2 (-6), P3 (-5), P4 (-3), P5 (-1), P6 (-1) C6: 74 (medium): P1 (-10), P2 (-6), P3 (-5), P4 (-3), P5 (-1), P6 (-1) C7: 74 (medium): P1 (-10), P2 (-6), P3 (-5), P4 (-3), P5 (-1), P6 (-1) C8: 73 (medium): P1 (-10), P2 (-6), P3 (-5), P4 (-3), P5 (-1), P6 (-1), P9 (-1) C9: 81 (high): P1 (-10), P2 (-6), P5 (-1), P6 (-1), P9 (-1) C10: 81 (high): P1 (-10), P2 (-6), P5 (-1), P6 (-1), P9 (-1) C11: 81 (high): P1 (-10), P2 (-6), P5 (-1), P6 (-1), P9 (-1)