{
 "bundle_of": "C27",
 "schema_version": "0.43",
 "paper": {
  "id": "entrylib:2026.000008",
  "version": 2,
  "title": "Evaluating forecasts and classifiers: which measures, scoring rules and tests to use",
  "licence": "CC-BY-4.0",
  "status": "corrected",
  "date": "2026-11-14",
  "status_notice": {
   "date": "2026-11-14",
   "reason_code": "correction",
   "statement": "Version 1 labelled the review's findings and recommendations extension, with an extends relation to the very works cited as their evidence, which said they extend those works; they state what those works establish, so version 2 labels them synthesis (claimset v0.43) and drops those relations, keeping extension only for C16, the one rule that goes beyond its sources, which extends Gneiting and Raftery (2007); and, at the guarantor's request, it rewords C3 (RMSSE as an example of the scaling), C4 (MAE and MASE as the main measure only when the mean and median forecasts coincide), C8 (absolute-error measures avoided on intermittent series), C13 (sharpness compared only among calibrated distributions and intervals) and C24 (choose a measure for what the methods predict, even if precedent used another).",
   "issued_by": "Ivan Svetunkov (ORCID 0000-0001-7826-0281)"
  }
 },
 "extensions": {
  "review": "0.1"
 },
 "claims": [
  {
   "id": "C27",
   "statement": "When quantile forecasts are compared over series on different scales, each series' [[D12:pinball loss]] should be scaled by a quantity of that series.",
   "about": {
    "subject": "D12",
    "relation": "should be scaled per series over",
    "object": "series on different scales",
    "comparator": null,
    "conditions": []
   },
   "type": "methodological",
   "role": "principal",
   "novelty": "synthesis",
   "support": [
    {
     "kind": "argument",
     "warrant": "W27"
    }
   ],
   "provenance": "author_stated",
   "hypothesis": {
    "lab_event": "H87",
    "outcome": "supported"
   },
   "planning": "exploratory",
   "depends_on": [
    "C48",
    "C34",
    "C44"
   ],
   "scope": {
    "data_type": "quantile forecasts over series on different scales"
   },
   "ext": {
    "review": {
     "kind": "recommendation"
    }
   },
   "limitations": [
    "L5"
   ],
   "assessments": [
    {
     "by": "author",
     "strength": "high",
     "rationale": "Exploratory in the lab's terms: a literature claim, stated from the guide before its papers were read, then confirmed against them (the status of its hypothesis in the lab record); no test was planned or run. It follows by the argument of its warrant from findings that its works state, quoted from full texts or read in full by the guarantor."
    }
   ],
   "verifiability": "open",
   "verifiability_flags": []
  },
  {
   "id": "C34",
   "statement": "The [[D12:pinball loss]] at a level is a [[D1:consistent scoring function]] for the quantile at that level.",
   "about": {
    "subject": "D12",
    "relation": "is consistent for",
    "object": "the quantile at its level",
    "comparator": null,
    "conditions": []
   },
   "type": "methodological",
   "role": "supporting",
   "novelty": "synthesis",
   "support": [
    {
     "kind": "cited",
     "reference": "B2",
     "locator": "Abstract; Theorem 3.3 (arXiv:0912.0902 numbering)"
    }
   ],
   "provenance": "author_stated",
   "hypothesis": {
    "lab_event": "H41",
    "outcome": "supported"
   },
   "planning": "exploratory",
   "ext": {
    "review": {
     "extracts": [
      {
       "reference": "B2",
       "locator": "Abstract; Theorem 3.3 (arXiv:0912.0902 numbering)",
       "lab_event": "XT7",
       "exact": "It is consistent for a quantile if and only if it is generalized piecewise linear",
       "prefix": "                      function. ",
       "suffix": ".\n                              ",
       "start": 3351,
       "end": 3432,
       "artefact": "A1"
      }
     ],
     "kind": "summary"
    }
   },
   "scope": {
    "data_type": "quantile forecasts"
   },
   "limitations": [
    "L3",
    "L5"
   ],
   "verifiability": "open",
   "verifiability_flags": []
  },
  {
   "id": "C44",
   "statement": "Scale-dependent error measures, such as [[D5:RMSE]] and [[D7:MAE]], cannot be compared across series on different scales.",
   "about": {
    "subject": "scale-dependent error measures",
    "relation": "cannot be compared across",
    "object": "series on different scales",
    "comparator": null,
    "conditions": []
   },
   "type": "methodological",
   "role": "supporting",
   "novelty": "synthesis",
   "support": [
    {
     "kind": "cited",
     "reference": "B6",
     "locator": "Section 2.1 (Scale-dependent measures)"
    },
    {
     "kind": "cited",
     "reference": "B6",
     "locator": "Section 2.4 (Relative measures)"
    }
   ],
   "provenance": "author_stated",
   "hypothesis": {
    "lab_event": "H51",
    "outcome": "supported"
   },
   "planning": "exploratory",
   "ext": {
    "review": {
     "extracts": [
      {
       "reference": "B6",
       "locator": "Section 2.1 (Scale-dependent measures)",
       "lab_event": "XT17",
       "exact": "should\nnot be used, for example, when comparing across data sets that have different scales",
       "prefix": "ds on the same set of data, but ",
       "suffix": ". Never-\ntheless, the MSE was us",
       "start": 13183,
       "end": 13274,
       "artefact": "A7"
      },
      {
       "reference": "B6",
       "locator": "Section 2.4 (Relative measures)",
       "lab_event": "XT18",
       "exact": "It makes no sense to compute the MAE across series (due to their different scales)",
       "prefix": "horizon across multiple\nseries. ",
       "suffix": ".\n\nA related approach is to use ",
       "start": 21483,
       "end": 21565,
       "artefact": "A7"
      }
     ],
     "kind": "summary"
    }
   },
   "scope": {
    "data_type": "error measures over series on different scales"
   },
   "limitations": [
    "L3",
    "L5"
   ],
   "verifiability": "open",
   "verifiability_flags": []
  },
  {
   "id": "C48",
   "statement": "The M5 uncertainty competition scored quantile forecasts with the scaled pinball loss: each series' [[D12:pinball loss]] divided by the in-sample mean absolute error of its one-step naive forecast.",
   "about": {
    "subject": "the scaled pinball loss",
    "relation": "scored quantile forecasts in",
    "object": "the M5 uncertainty competition",
    "comparator": null,
    "conditions": []
   },
   "type": "methodological",
   "role": "supporting",
   "novelty": "synthesis",
   "support": [
    {
     "kind": "cited",
     "reference": "B1",
     "locator": "Probabilistic forecasts"
    },
    {
     "kind": "cited",
     "reference": "B10"
    }
   ],
   "provenance": "author_stated",
   "hypothesis": {
    "lab_event": "H55",
    "outcome": "supported"
   },
   "planning": "exploratory",
   "ext": {
    "review": {
     "extracts": [
      {
       "reference": "B1",
       "locator": "Probabilistic forecasts",
       "lab_event": "XT22",
       "exact": "The precision of the probabilistic forecasts will be evaluated using the Scaled Pinball Loss (SPL) function",
       "prefix": "ition.\n\nProbabilistic forecasts\n",
       "suffix": ".\nThe measure is calculated for ",
       "start": 17832,
       "end": 17939,
       "artefact": "A9"
      }
     ],
     "kind": "summary"
    }
   },
   "scope": {
    "data_type": "quantile forecasts in the M5 uncertainty competition"
   },
   "limitations": [
    "L5",
    "L6"
   ],
   "verifiability": "open",
   "verifiability_flags": []
  }
 ],
 "definitions": [
  {
   "id": "D1",
   "term": "consistent scoring function",
   "kind": "concept",
   "definition": "A scoring function (an error measure for point forecasts) is consistent for a functional of the predictive distribution, such as the mean, the median or a quantile, when its expected value is lowest when the point forecast equals that functional.",
   "source": "B2"
  },
  {
   "id": "D5",
   "term": "RMSE",
   "kind": "variable",
   "definition": "Root mean squared error: the square root of the mean of the squared differences between outcomes and point forecasts.",
   "source": "B6"
  },
  {
   "id": "D7",
   "term": "MAE",
   "kind": "variable",
   "definition": "Mean absolute error: the mean of the absolute differences between outcomes and point forecasts.",
   "source": "B6"
  },
  {
   "id": "D12",
   "term": "pinball loss",
   "kind": "variable",
   "definition": "The quantile (asymmetric piecewise linear) loss at level tau: tau times the error when the outcome is above the forecast, and (1 - tau) times the absolute error when it is below.",
   "source": "B2"
  }
 ],
 "warrants": [
  {
   "id": "W27",
   "reasoning": "deductive",
   "premises": [
    "C48",
    "C34",
    "C44"
   ],
   "text": "Pinball losses of series on different scales cannot be compared unscaled; dividing each series' pinball loss by a quantity of that series that does not depend on the forecasts keeps the quantile it is consistent for, as the scaled pinball loss of the M5 uncertainty competition does."
  }
 ],
 "limitations": [
  {
   "id": "L3",
   "category": "measurement",
   "statement": "Section and theorem numbers for Gneiting 2011, Gneiting and Raftery 2007, Gneiting, Balabdaoui and Raftery 2007 and Hyndman and Koehler 2006 were read in their preprints or authors' copies (arXiv:0912.0902 and the authors' web pages), whose numbering may differ from the published versions.",
   "affects": [
    "C29",
    "C30",
    "C31",
    "C32",
    "C33",
    "C34",
    "C35",
    "C36",
    "C37",
    "C38",
    "C39",
    "C44",
    "C46"
   ],
   "impact": "reduces_precision",
   "mitigation": "none"
  },
  {
   "id": "L5",
   "category": "researcher_position",
   "statement": "The claims restate EntryLib's study-planning guide on prediction, drafted by an agent of the same system that checked them here, and were stated before the works were read; the works were read to confirm what the guide states, and no search was run for work that disagrees with it.",
   "affects": [
    "C1",
    "C2",
    "C3",
    "C4",
    "C5",
    "C6",
    "C7",
    "C8",
    "C9",
    "C10",
    "C11",
    "C12",
    "C13",
    "C14",
    "C15",
    "C16",
    "C17",
    "C18",
    "C19",
    "C20",
    "C21",
    "C22",
    "C23",
    "C24",
    "C25",
    "C26",
    "C27",
    "C28",
    "C29",
    "C30",
    "C31",
    "C32",
    "C33",
    "C34",
    "C35",
    "C36",
    "C37",
    "C38",
    "C39",
    "C40",
    "C41",
    "C42",
    "C43",
    "C44",
    "C45",
    "C46",
    "C47",
    "C48",
    "C49",
    "C50",
    "C51",
    "C52",
    "C53"
   ],
   "impact": "could_bias_magnitude",
   "mitigation": "none"
  },
  {
   "id": "L6",
   "category": "data_quality",
   "statement": "These claims rest in part on works read in full by the guarantor, not by the agent that wrote the claimset (lab note NT14); no passage of those works is quoted, so a reader checks these claims against the works themselves.",
   "affects": [
    "C30",
    "C33",
    "C40",
    "C41",
    "C45",
    "C47",
    "C48",
    "C49",
    "C52",
    "C53"
   ],
   "impact": "reduces_precision",
   "mitigation": "none"
  }
 ],
 "artefacts": [
  {
   "id": "A1",
   "kind": "data",
   "version": "sha256:6b6cc2f0fd3daa1da42506f42f05fe88425880b2806f864ceaab85fc606ab5c9",
   "description": "Making and evaluating point forecasts (arXiv:0912.0902, the preprint of Gneiting 2011, JASA 106(494), 746-762, doi:10.1198/jasa.2011.r10138) (application/pdf), saved by hand on 2026-11-13; recorded in the lab record as SR1 on 2026-11-13. venue: arXiv. Written by others.",
   "uri": "https://arxiv.org/abs/0912.0902",
   "availability": {
    "level": "author_only",
    "reason": "legal",
    "content_hash": "sha256:6b6cc2f0fd3daa1da42506f42f05fe88425880b2806f864ceaab85fc606ab5c9"
   },
   "reference": "B2"
  },
  {
   "id": "A7",
   "kind": "data",
   "version": "sha256:b86b2d78457b62195faa87e2071beb3cacea2d6cb413c296dab746b00bb90a80",
   "description": "Another look at measures of forecast accuracy (preprint of Hyndman and Koehler 2006, IJF 22(4), 679-688, doi:10.1016/j.ijforecast.2006.03.001) (application/pdf), saved by hand on 2026-11-13; recorded in the lab record as SR7 on 2026-11-13. venue: International Journal of Forecasting. Written by others.",
   "uri": "https://robjhyndman.com/papers/mase.pdf",
   "availability": {
    "level": "author_only",
    "reason": "legal",
    "content_hash": "sha256:b86b2d78457b62195faa87e2071beb3cacea2d6cb413c296dab746b00bb90a80"
   },
   "reference": "B6"
  },
  {
   "id": "A9",
   "kind": "data",
   "version": "sha256:f2650a2dbfb14d2c7d4482bda66c129ce5eec9341a76b76a833219559bf17109",
   "description": "The M5 Competition: Competitors' Guide (the organisers' definition of the RMSSE, the scaled pinball loss and the reasons for them) (application/pdf), saved by hand on 2026-11-13; recorded in the lab record as SR9 on 2026-11-13. venue: M Open Forecasting Center, GitHub repository Mcompetitions/M5-methods. Written by others.",
   "uri": "https://github.com/Mcompetitions/M5-methods/blob/master/M5-Competitors-Guide.pdf",
   "availability": {
    "level": "author_only",
    "reason": "legal",
    "content_hash": "sha256:f2650a2dbfb14d2c7d4482bda66c129ce5eec9341a76b76a833219559bf17109"
   },
   "reference": "B1"
  }
 ],
 "references": [
  {
   "id": "B1",
   "target": "https://github.com/Mcompetitions/M5-methods/blob/master/M5-Competitors-Guide.pdf",
   "id_type": "url",
   "ext": {
    "review": {
     "read": "full_text",
     "version": "other",
     "checked_on": "2026-11-13",
     "artefact": "A9",
     "lab_event": "SC9"
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "B2",
   "target": "10.1198/jasa.2011.r10138",
   "id_type": "doi",
   "ext": {
    "review": {
     "read": "full_text",
     "version": "preprint",
     "checked_on": "2026-11-13",
     "artefact": "A1",
     "lab_event": "SC1"
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "B6",
   "target": "10.1016/j.ijforecast.2006.03.001",
   "id_type": "doi",
   "ext": {
    "review": {
     "read": "full_text",
     "version": "author_copy",
     "checked_on": "2026-11-13",
     "artefact": "A7",
     "lab_event": "SC7"
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "id": "B10",
   "target": "10.1016/j.ijforecast.2021.10.009",
   "id_type": "doi",
   "ext": {
    "review": {
     "read": "full_text",
     "checked_on": "2026-11-13",
     "lab_event": "SC12"
    }
   }
  }
 ]
}
